The List

Anniversary songs, and which ones are actually about the anniversary

Most anniversary song lists have one flaw in common. They treat a couple on their first anniversary and a couple on their fortieth as the same customer.

They are not. Half the songs that get recommended for an anniversary are about the wedding day, or the first kiss, or love finally showing up. Fine songs. Wrong year. Here are ten, sorted honestly, with the facts attached.

The ones about growing old together

These are the anniversary songs. They are about staying, not starting.

“Remember When” by Alan Jackson, released October 2003, written by Jackson alone. Number one on Billboard’s Hot Country Songs in February 2004 and certified five times platinum. It follows one marriage from its beginning through raising children into old age, and the video Trey Fanjoy directed features Jackson’s wife Denise, with their home movies cut in. If you only play one song on this page at a twenty-fifth, play this one.

“Through the Years” by Kenny Rogers, 1981, written by Steve Dorff and Marty Panzer. Number thirteen on the Hot 100, number one Adult Contemporary, eleven weeks in the Top 40. It is about a long relationship’s ups and downs and the decision to keep going. Rogers called it one of his career songs and performed it at the 1983 Grammys, and again for his fiftieth-anniversary special with Lionel Richie and Dolly Parton.

“Then” by Brad Paisley, 2009, written by Chris DuBois, Ashley Gorley and Paisley. Number one on Hot Country Songs in June 2009, his tenth consecutive chart-topper, double platinum. It walks back through the milestones, first meeting, first kiss, the proposal in the place they met, and says the love has outgrown every one of them. That is an anniversary sentiment exactly.

“Grow Old with Me” by John Lennon, released in 1984 on Milk and Honey, three years after his death. The lyric sheet is dated July 1980. Lennon took the idea from a Robert Browning poem he found in Bermuda and wrote it as a companion piece to Yoko Ono’s “Let Me Count the Ways.” He and Ono meant it to become a church standard for weddings. What was released is a bedroom cassette, piano and a rhythm box. Mary Chapin Carpenter’s 1995 version reached number seventeen Adult Contemporary, and Ringo Starr recorded it in 2019 with Paul McCartney on bass.

The ones that are really wedding songs

Beautiful, and about the beginning. Play them at the reception, not the anniversary dinner.

“At Last”, written in 1941 by Mack Gordon and Harry Warren for the Glenn Miller film Sun Valley Serenade. Miller’s 1942 recording went to number two. Etta James cut the version everyone knows in 1960, and it went into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1999 and the Library of Congress National Recording Registry in 2009. Beyoncé sang it for the Obamas’ first dance in 2009. It is a song about love arriving after a long wait, which is the wedding, not the anniversary.

“I Cross My Heart” by George Strait, from the 1992 film Pure Country, written a decade earlier by Steve Dorff and Eric Kaz. Bette Midler recorded a piano version in 1984 that never came out, and Dorff pitched it as the film’s closing ballad. Number one on Hot Country Songs in December 1992, triple platinum. It is a vow. Vows belong at the altar.

“Forever and Ever, Amen” by Randy Travis, 1987, written by Paul Overstreet and Don Schlitz. Three weeks at number one, Grammy for Best Country Song, CMA Song of the Year, double platinum. The title came from Schlitz’s small son, who told his mother after prayers that he loved her forever and ever, amen. It is a promise about the future. On an anniversary you already know how the promise went.

The ones that are something else entirely

“Have I Told You Lately” by Van Morrison, 1989, from Avalon Sunset. Morrison wrote it as a prayer. It became a wedding staple anyway, and Rod Stewart’s live 1993 version reached number five on the Hot 100 and spent five weeks at number one Adult Contemporary. It works at an anniversary because gratitude is the right note for one, but it was never about a marriage.

“When You Say Nothing at All”, written by Paul Overstreet and Don Schlitz again, at the end of a dry writing day, and thought merely acceptable until Keith Whitley recorded it. Number one in December 1988, five months before Whitley died at thirty-four. Alison Krauss’s 1995 version, cut for a Whitley tribute album, won CMA Single of the Year. It is about a couple who understand each other without talking, which is a thing long marriages have and short ones do not, so it earns a place here on a technicality.

“Longer” by Dan Fogelberg, 1979, number two on the Hot 100 for two weeks and number one Adult Contemporary. Fogelberg wrote it in a hammock in Maui looking at the stars, and later joked it was the song that put him on the elevators. It measures devotion against mountains and oceans. It does not mention a year, an argument, or a mortgage.

What the sorting tells you

Overstreet and Schlitz wrote two of these ten. Steve Dorff wrote two more. Four songwriters account for nearly half the list, which is worth knowing if you like one and want its cousins.

And of the ten, four are about the long haul: “Remember When,” “Through the Years,” “Then,” and “Grow Old with Me.” The other six are about the day it started. They still get played at anniversaries constantly, and there is nothing wrong with that. But if you are thirty years in and looking for a song that knows it, the shortlist is four, and the first three are country.

If none of these is about the two of you

They are not. Every song above is about somebody else’s marriage.

That is the whole reason I write custom ones. You send the true story of the two of you, the year you met, the thing he still says, the road trip that went wrong, the house you almost did not buy, and you get an original song about it. Country if that is you. Folk, rock, blues, gospel, or something cinematic if it is not. The order form lists seven genre families and asks what the occasion is, and anniversary is the second option on the list.

It starts at $79, delivered in five to fourteen days with the files and a lyric sheet, and the custom songs page has the tiers and the straight answers. Most orders are gifts. Tell me the date.

More lists like this one

The same honest treatment is on the fishing songs list, where it turns out most famous fishing songs are not about fishing either. Everything I have released is free to play on the listen page, how the songs get made is on how it works, and when one of mine gets a fact wrong the correction goes on the fact checks page.