The List
Songs about fishing, and which ones are actually about fishing
Most lists of fishing songs start in about 2002 and stop at whoever is on country radio this year. The genre is a great deal older than that, and several of its best-known entries are not about fishing at all.
Here is the list with the facts attached: who wrote each one, when, and what it is really about.
1911
It starts in 1911, not in Nashville
“Fishin’ Blues” was written by Chris Smith in 1911, under the plainer title “Fishing.” The first recording came seventeen years later, in 1928, from Ragtime Texas Henry Thomas, who played guitar and quills on it. That recording went into Harry Smith’s Anthology of American Folk Music, which is how most of the twentieth century met it.
Then the twist, and the Library of Congress is the source for it: the 1911 original was a revenge song written from the perspective of a wronged wife. The cheerful fishing song everybody knows is a later reading of it.
The Lovin’ Spoonful recorded it in 1965, John Martyn in 1968, Taj Mahal in 1969, and the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band in 2002. It has outlived nearly everything else on this page.
The standards
The two standards
“Gone Fishin’”, written by Nick and Charles Kenny in 1950 and carried into permanence by Bing Crosby and Louis Armstrong trading lines. If you picture a fishing song before you picture any particular one, this is usually the shape of it.
“The Fishin’ Hole”, 1961, better known as the whistled theme from The Andy Griffith Show. Music by Earl Hagen and Herbert Spencer, lyrics by Everett Sloane. Almost nobody knows it has words.
The famous one
The one everybody names, which is not about fishing
“Fishin’ in the Dark” by the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band, released 7 June 1987, written by Wendy Waldman and Jim Photoglo. It went to number one on Billboard’s Hot Country Songs and has since gone platinum.
It is also not a fishing song. It is a song about a couple slipping off at night, and the fishing is the excuse. That is worth saying out loud on a page like this, because it is the single most-cited fishing song in America and the fishing is scenery.
Number one
The joke that went to number one
“I’m Gonna Miss Her (The Fishin’ Song)” by Brad Paisley, released 25 February 2002, written by Paisley and Frank Rogers. Number one on Hot Country Songs for two weeks from 6 July 2002, his third chart-topper.
The origin is better than the song. Paisley was a student at Belmont University in Nashville in the early nineties, asked to play a student concert. Rogers suggested they write something that would make people laugh. It worked well enough that it sat unreleased for a decade, passed over for his debut because Rogers thought it needed a bigger artist. Garth Brooks and George Strait both wanted it. Paisley kept it.
The honest one
The one that is genuinely about fishing
“Just Fishin’” by Trace Adkins, 2011, written by Casey Beathard, Monty Criswell and Ed Hill. It reached number six on Hot Country Songs.
A father is fishing with his small daughter. She is counting fish. He is counting something else. It is the most honest song on this list about what the day is actually for, and it is the one most likely to catch a parent off guard in the truck.
The two that use the water for something bigger
"Catfish John", written by Bob McDill and Allen Reynolds, first released on McDill's 1972 album Short Stories and cut as a single by Johnny Russell in November 1972, where it reached number twelve. Alison Krauss recorded it. So did the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band, and Jerry Garcia played it for years.
It is not a fishing song either. It is about a man who had been enslaved, remembered by a boy who was told to stay away from him and did not.
"Fisherman's Blues" by The Waterboys, written by Mike Scott and Steve Wickham, title track of the October 1988 album. Number three on Billboard's Modern Rock chart. The fisherman in it is a thing the singer wishes he were, not a thing he is.
And three of mine, since this is my site
I write Western and Americana ballads and I am not going to pretend otherwise on my own list. All three of these are genuinely about fly fishing, which puts them in a smaller category than most of the above.
"Run of the River" is a day on Colorado's Western Slope, from the Roaring Fork and the Gunnison to the stillwaters on the Grand Mesa. Real water, fished with my son and a guide who knows it better than we do. The story behind it is in the Run of the River post.
"Turn the Rock" is the same river earlier in the morning: turn the rock, see what is under it, match the hatch. More on that in the Turn the Rock post.
"Skinny Water Gold" leaves the mountains for salt water: sight-fishing for redfish on the flats outside Corpus Christi, where you get one clean cast at a copper tail.
All three were made with AI assistance, which I disclose on how it works, and all three were rewritten line by line by somebody who owns waders.
So which ones are actually about fishing?
Of the eight songs above, three are really about fishing: "Fishin' Blues" in its later reading, "Just Fishin'", and "The Fishin' Hole".
"Fishin' in the Dark" is about a date. "Catfish John" is about a man. "Fisherman's Blues" is about wanting to be somewhere else. "Gone Fishin'" is about not being at work. "I'm Gonna Miss Her" is about choosing the lake over the marriage, which is funnier than it is accurate.
That is not a complaint. Fishing turns out to be one of the most useful metaphors in American songwriting precisely because everybody already knows what it feels like to wait for something that may not come.
But if you came here looking for songs about actually standing in water, it is a shorter list than the internet suggests.
Where the rest of the catalog is
Everything I have recorded is free to play on the listen page, sixty-eight ballads covering three hundred years of the American West. When one of my own songs gets a fact wrong, the correction goes on the fact checks page rather than quietly into a new version.
If you know a fishing song that belongs here and is not on the list, send it. Particularly an old one. The good ones tend to be older than people expect.
